Judge.me vs Stamped.io Pricing by Order Volume

Judge.me is the cheaper choice at every store size: it costs $0 on Forever Free or $15 a month on Awesome, with no order meter. Stamped.io costs $23 a month up to 200 orders, $99 up to 1,000 and $199 up to 5,000, and sells Loyalty separately at $299. Stamped earns its higher price only when you want reviews and a loyalty program from one vendor, or you already depend on its workflows. For a store that just needs product reviews, the gap is $1,000 to $2,200 a year in Judge.me's favor once you pass 200 orders.

Both apps are Shopify review apps with photo and video reviews, email requests, on-site widgets and Google ratings. The difference is how they charge. Judge.me charges for features, and only one paid plan exists. Stamped charges for order volume, and every Reviews tier has the same features. Judge.me figures below come from its Shopify App Store listing and help center, read October 1, 2026. Stamped figures come from its Shopify App Store listing, read October 5, 2026. All prices are US dollars.

Judge.me vs Stamped.io at a glance

Judge.me vs Stamped.io cost by order volume

Order volume is the whole story on price. Judge.me never reads your order count, while Stamped moves you up a tier at 200 and at 1,000 orders. Here is what the cheapest plan with reviews costs on each app, assuming you want the paid Judge.me plan for Klaviyo and reminders.

If you can live on Judge.me Free, the yearly gap grows by another $180 at every row. Stores between 150 and 250 orders should pay attention to the first jump: one strong month moves Stamped from $23 to $99. If you already forecast holiday order volume to plan stock, use the same number to pick the Stamped tier, because the busiest month sets the price, not the average. The full Stamped ladder, including Loyalty, is on our Stamped.io pricing page, and the Judge.me plans are broken down on Judge.me pricing.

Is Stamped better than Judge.me?

Stamped is better for a store that wants reviews and loyalty from one vendor, and Judge.me is better for almost everyone else. Feature for feature on reviews alone, the two are close: both collect photo and video reviews by email, show widgets and star badges, and send ratings to Google. Stamped's case rests on its loyalty product and on Klaviyo being included at $23, not on better reviews.

Stamped's Shopify listing names integrations with Klaviyo, Gorgias, Recharge, Shopify Flow, Google Shopping, Facebook and Instagram, and its display options cover testimonials, photo and video reviews, star ratings, voting, badges and carousels. Its Loyalty product adds points, discounts, free shipping and free product rewards, VIP tiers and referrals, with email and SMS templates. Merchant reviews on the listing (4.7 out of 5 from about 3,750 ratings when we read it) single out hands-on setup and migration help, which matters if you are moving a large catalog.

Is Judge.me cheaper than Stamped?

Yes, at every order volume. Judge.me tops out at $15 a month, and Stamped starts at $23. The more a store sells, the wider the gap, because Stamped's price climbs with orders and Judge.me's does not. At 2,500 orders a month the difference is $184 a month, or $2,208 a year.

Judge.me's free plan is also the most generous in the category. Forever Free includes unlimited product and store reviews, unlimited photo and video reviews, unlimited review requests, the review widget, star badges, carousels, rich snippets, Google reviews sync and the review importer. The $15 Awesome plan adds Klaviyo and more than 130 other integrations, auto reminders, Q&A, coupons, Google Shopping, Meta and TikTok Shop sync, AI replies and full design control.

When Stamped is worth the extra money

There are three situations where paying Stamped makes sense over Judge.me.

• You want a loyalty program anyway. If you were going to pay for a separate loyalty app, Stamped Reviews plus Loyalty in one admin is a real convenience. At 3,000 orders that pair costs $498 a month, so compare it against Judge.me plus your preferred loyalty app, not against Judge.me alone.
• You need Klaviyo at the lowest tier and are under 200 orders. Stamped Reviews at $23 includes Klaviyo. Judge.me needs Awesome at $15 for it, which is still cheaper, so this only matters if another Stamped feature tips the balance.
• Your team already runs on Stamped. Flows, templates and widget styling built over years cost real hours to rebuild. Moving to save $84 a month at 500 orders is easy to justify. Moving a large store mid-season to save the same amount often is not.

Can I move my reviews from Stamped to Judge.me?

Yes. Judge.me includes a review importer on its Forever Free plan, so you can export your reviews from Stamped and import them without paying for Awesome first. Keep Stamped installed until the imported reviews show correctly on your product pages, because uninstalling a review app removes its widgets and star ratings from your theme straight away. Check your rich snippets in Search Console a week after the switch.

Which one should a Shopify store pick?

If you are weighing other order-priced apps too, our Judge.me vs Loox comparison runs the same numbers against Loox's photo-first plans, Okendo vs Judge.me does the same for Okendo, and Fera reviews pricing covers the cheapest order-priced app we have read.

What neither review app collects

Judge.me and Stamped both ask buyers to review the product they bought. That is the right proof for a product page, and it leaves a gap on the homepage, the about page and the wholesale page, where a first time visitor is deciding whether to trust the brand at all. A wholesale buyer, a retail partner or a long-time customer telling the story of why they keep ordering never gets a review request, because the request is triggered by an order.

That is the job a testimonial tool does. You send one link to anyone, they record a short video or write a few lines with no login, consent to publish is stored with the submission, and the result goes on a Wall of Love you embed with one line of code. Our plans are priced by walls, brands and seats, never by orders: Starter is $49 a month or $288 a year for one wall, which sits alongside either review app rather than replacing it. The Shopify testimonials page shows where these stories go on a store and how to collect the first ten.